Some fuel pumps need to be spaced very precisely to achieve the proper fuel pressure. On some engines the fuel pressure can be raised or lowered by using different thickness gaskets. Look through your service manual to see if this is the case. You can check the new pump fitness by covering the inlet port and cycling the pump. I would advise against swapping parts between the two pumps.
Not really the case here but maybe I'm wrong as I see the Fiat pumps come in a variety of thickness (0.3mm - 1.2 mm) and they are very similar in design (in fact the gaskets are the same shape). I used the paper gaskets that came with the pump for Alfa AR30550 and I've used various gaskets from different sources with the old original pump and it still worked.
I think maybe a thinner gasket might be worth trying.
To go back the your hard starting after several days of non-use issue, I have a few thoughts. When you are running an engine the intake runner and port are completely soaked with gasoline. The runners/ports will stay wet for some time aiding in re-starting the engine. If the time period between re-start is long enough the gasoline will have evaporated making starting difficult until there is sufficient gasoline added to the intake tract. Poor choke adjustment will make starting difficult even if there is sufficient fuel. Check that the choke plate is fully closed when reset
Inadequate accelerator pump discharge volume because of poor adjustment or under-sized orifice will add to the difficultly. On some carbs the accelerator pump movement can be phased in regard to throttle plate movement causing a later and lower than expected pump discharge. Any or all of these can also result in a stumble when shifting from 1st to 2nd gear because of the rapid change in throttle position and rpm, resulting in a lean condition even when using a stock cam..
Chokes are disconnected and aren't ever used.
I only use (like many other boxers users I know) the pump jets to start the engine.
2/3 pumps is always sufficient.
Here the engine will always start straight away but the pump doesn't appear to be priming properly after 5-6 days of non use.
Carbs really require no more effort than the type you have already displayed in getting to this point with your project. Write down what changes you make and how the engine reacts.
Thanks Tim.
I will try the pump again but this time using a syringe to completely fill the inside chamber before trying to start to see what happens.
If all else fails it could be a worn oil pump shaft lobe. (solution: electric fuel pump)
The time I spent yesterday on this I could have had an electric fuel pump fitted and wired up! Fustrating at times. Thought it would have been a 30 min job.